Below are listed the winners and nominees of the 2017 Cóyotl Awards. The winners are listed first and in bold.

Best Novel

• Kismet by Watts Martin
• Always Gray in Winter by Mark J. Engels
• reWritten by Jako Malan
• The Tower and the Fox by Tim Susman

Best Novella

• Dragon Fried Cheese by Madison Keller
• The Earth Tigers by Frances Pauli
• Jazz at the End of the Night by Weasel
• The Pride of Parahumans by Joel Kreissman
• Sinful Behavior by Rukis

Best Short Story

• “Behesht” by Dwale
• “Clicking” by Ianus J. Wolf
• “Hollow” by Chris “Sparf” Williams
• “The Moon Fox” by Amy Fontaine
• “The Ouroboros Plate” by Slip Wolf
• “Personal History” by Tim Susman
• “Richard Cory” by Tristan Black Wolf

Best Anthology

• Arcana edited by Madison Scott-Clary
• Bleak Horizons edited by Tarl Hoch
• Symbol of a Nation edited by Fred Patten